The Cubs have finally taken a bold step towards their dream offseason, and it's time to celebrate! But here's where it gets controversial: some are suggesting they trade away a key player, Nico Hoerner.
This front office has had its eye on starting pitcher Edward Cabrera for a while, and they recently acquired him. They've also been pursuing Alex Bregman, and on a thrilling Chicago sports evening, the Cubs secured him with a $175 million, five-year deal.
Chicago fans are thrilled, but the mood could change if Hoerner is traded. It's not just about the financial flexibility it might provide; Hoerner is a team leader, an elite defender, and an above-average hitter. Trading him would be a step backward, especially when the Cubs appear to be contenders on paper.
There's no indication the Cubs are actively seeking a trade, but other teams are interested, and the Cubs might listen if the offer is irresistible. However, a win-now team should prioritize keeping Hoerner. His WAR (Wins Above Replacement) is impressive, and he's consistently performed well, winning Gold Gloves and earning MVP votes.
Hoerner brings an intangible quality too - a model-heavy front office still values that aspect. It's why they brought in Justin Turner and pursued Bregman. As manager Craig Counsell said, "Nico's great at things others think they're good at, but he's exceptional."
Trading Hoerner might replenish the farm system, but it would also remove his leadership and impact on the team. His teammates would likely be unhappy, and it could hurt the team's chances of winning. The luxury tax shouldn't be a concern for a team like the Cubs, who consistently draw large crowds.
The Cubs have often taken half-measures, but now they're finally acting like a big-market team. They hired Counsell, traded for Tucker, and acquired Bregman. It's time to keep the momentum going and take control of their division. Trading Hoerner would be a step in the wrong direction.
So, what do you think? Should the Cubs keep Hoerner or explore trade options? Let's discuss in the comments!
